1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
Dismiss Notice
Hey Guest!
The donation button is here.
Dismiss Notice
Guest, some new updates and fixes were done. Please let staff know if anything is funky or wonky!!!

Star Wars: Rogue One

Discussion in 'Tilted Entertainment' started by MeltedMetalGlob, Apr 7, 2016.

  1. martian

    martian Server Monkey Staff Member

    So guys, it's totally cool to take my week old baby to the theatre so I can go see this, right?

    Avoiding spoilers until it's out on blu ray is going to be a bitch.
  2. Borla

    Borla Moderator Staff Member Donor

    Sadly, newborn ears can be greatly damaged by that level of sound. My wife worked for an otolaryngologist for many years, and that was something that many parents never knew. My wife cringes any time we see a little baby at action movies, sporting events, or anywhere loud.
  3. martian

    martian Server Monkey Staff Member

    Yeah, taking a newborn to a movie theatre is not a thing I'd actually do. I'll just some day have to tell this kid how much I sacrificed for her benefit.
    Borla likes this.
  4. Daniel_

    Daniel_ The devil made me do it...

    No spoilers, but having seen it on Friday, I have to say it's the movie that I hoped it would be.

    K2SO may well be my favourite SW character of all time.

    I'm looking forward to the home release, because I really want to run it straight into New Hope... :)
    Borla likes this.
  5. Shadowex3

    Shadowex3 Very Tilted

    Fantastic movie, easily miles better than Force Awakens with incomparably better character writing. They really did Star Wars justice with this one although I'll admit being a little disappointed Kyle Katarn got written out of canon.

    I was also impressed they had the balls to make what is definitely not a happy movie. They should fire Jar Jar Abrams and his entire staff and have the Rogue One team unfuck the main continuity. MaRey Sue and The Mighty Janitor might just be saved by some serious retconning and good writing.

    Someone on the team had to be a KOTOR fan.
  6. Japchae

    Japchae Very Tilted

    It was entertaining.
    Borla likes this.
  7. redravin

    redravin Cynical Optimist Donor

    Excellent movie and really one of the best next to Empire Strikes Back.
    Borla likes this.
  8. Borla

    Borla Moderator Staff Member Donor

    Reading Catalyst just before going to the movie helped flesh out some of the back story with the Erso Family, Krennic, and Tarkin. Even Saw has a minor part in the book.

    In general I thought the movie was well done. I liked it nearly as much as Force Awakens, and it may even grow on me more when I see it a couple more times. Having two in a row that were among the best in the entire story line makes me pretty excited about the movies to come.

    (Very ambigious spoiler ahead.)

    I read one article that said Gareth Edwards had originally sketched out a different ending because he didn't think Disney would let him finish it the way he wanted to. Supposedly he was surprised that no one pushed him to adjust it at all. To me that gives reason for optimism that the movies to come won't have to fit a Disney story book ending either.
    cynthetiq likes this.
  9. cynthetiq

    cynthetiq Administrator Staff Member Donor

    New York City
    I didn't watch any trailers or anything about it just like Force Awakens and other Marvel movies. I don't buy into the hype machine because I just want to watch an escapism movie to escape. It doesn't have to be Shakespeare, it has to let me escape for a few hours.

    Saying that I just watched it this morning and look forward to another screening.
    redravin, ASU2003 and Borla like this.
  10. ASU2003

    ASU2003 Slightly Tilted

    Where ever I roam
    I thought it was a great movie. I also avoided any commercials or internet discussion ahead of time.

    The only nit-picky things were, there was no yellow scrolling text at the beginning. I'm not sure why it was cut out. I also think that R2-D2 and C-3PO should have had a few more lines. And in episode 4, they say the Emperor just dissolved the galactic senate, but I'm not sure how or when that really happened. (Not that it could have worked into this movie.)

    But, I did like the backstory of the rebellion that it told. And I wouldn't be surprised if there is another one or two that could be written.
  11. Lordeden

    Lordeden Sexy Man Beast Donor

    Redneckhell, NC
    I'm pretty sure they came out and said there would be no opening crawl for any "star wars stories" movies. Only canonical episodes get crawls.

    I think the fan service scenes were long enough, no more needed to be added. Any more lines from the cameos and it would have been to much.
    cynthetiq and Borla like this.
  12. SirLance

    SirLance Death Therapist

    I walked in with no idea what to expect, and it was awesome. What a good movie!
    bobby, ASU2003 and cynthetiq like this.
  13. cynthetiq

    cynthetiq Administrator Staff Member Donor

    New York City
    I thought the fan scenes were nice but if I had seen it in a full theatre with fanboys it would have been distracting.

    I already thought the location names were overdone and too pronounced but I guess that's today's people's expectations.
  14. CinnamonGirl

    CinnamonGirl Rounding third and heading for home Donor

    We saw it opening night. I thought it started off a little slow, but it was a slow burn that exploded towards the end. Pretty sure I cried the entire last 20 minutes BOTH times we saw it. Then
    that surprise cameo, and I started sobbing (this was before anything happened, it was just, uh, very emotional for me.)
    As the credits rolled, Eden looked over and said, "there's nothing post-credits."

    "I know," I answered. "I just need a minute."

    We've seen it twice, and I've been thinking about going again on Saturday.
    redravin, cynthetiq and Borla like this.
  15. rogue49

    rogue49 Tech Kung Fu Artist Staff Member Donor

    Good flick :cool:
    Not to much of "over-Force"....meaning having The Force overly manipulating a conflict situationally. (like previously, when little Anakin just happened to destroy a starship by accident...or Rey out duel a fully trained Sith)
    Decent physics (except the sound in space or visible slow lasers...but this gets a bye and doesn't count in StarWars)
    Hell, even the stormtroopers could shoot accurately and often gave as good as they got.
    Loved the technique of dealing with Star Destroyers
    And ya gotta like the new droid...with attitude.
    Good conflict, fairly real...felt like "Empire Strikes Back" in style.
    I even liked the CGI cameos (although this IS where acting is going...)

    Saw Passengers after...great Sci-Fi Rom-Com...like "When Harry Met Sally" in outer space. I recommend it. :)
  16. ASU2003

    ASU2003 Slightly Tilted

    Where ever I roam
    I'm not sure about the new droid. It seemed like a marketing gimmick to sell toys instead of a real character since I don't remember that model in any of the 4 movies that are supposed to happen after that. The R2 units were the ones that were missing from the X-wing fighters.

    And I also saw Passengers, and it was a great sci-fi movie too. It was not what I was expecting it to be either.
    rogue49 likes this.
  17. Yerba

    Yerba ...wait, what?

    Nowhere, KS
    Saw it a couple of weeks ago. Will probably see it again when it hits a cheaper theatre in a few months.

    I'm terrible about revealing spoilers, so I'll just say that I enjoyed it and will watch it again.
    martian likes this.